Horde3D

Hi, I had a try with Intel Threading Building Blocks today to make the software skinning parallel. Here is my results after 4 hours of reading the TBB manual and integrating that into the Horde3D :
I'm getting those results on an Intel Core2 Quad 2.83GHz, and overall CPU usage staying about 45%. Here is the Patch and Binaries if anybody is interested.
[You need Intel TBB 3.0 and #define H3D_USE_TBB in order to compile the parallel code.]

Best Regards, Siavash.

Did you also tried using OpenMP? Would be less intel specific.

Not really, AFAIK OpenMP is not available by default to MSVC Express users so that should be a cons. But in other hand Intel TBB is widely being used by products such as Maya, UnrealEngine and lot more and is available at Linux repositories too (Ubuntu, Fedora, Gentoo and ...)

If you mean that final code will be running slower on non-Intel CPU manufactures, no, IMHO TBB runs everywhere fine. If you are concerned about the license, well it's licensed under GPL v2 with the libstdC++ Runtime Exception. Is it problematic?

As long as Horde is only licensed under EPL, yes it is. Didn't know that TBB is also working on AMD CPUs.

I'm really confused What I thought from here is that it won't affect the Horde3D. Also here people say that it's OK to use Intel TBB in commercial products too without any problems. Here is a bit taken from libstdc++ FAQ :


Also I asked a few questions at #FSF before and there where no problems. Please correct me if I'm wrong somewhere.

I haven't read the exception text. I guess you're right that it doesn't affect Horde if one would use TBB.

You are correct. TBB is offerered under the same license (GPL + linking exception) as the std library, and as such can be used commercially or uin open-source projects.

The separate 'commercial license' which Intel sells, is for commercial support, and gives you extensive technical support (which the free license doesn't have).

_________________
Tristam MacDonald - [swiftcoding]