Horde3D

I don't know you know or not, but currently I'm busy with optimizing utMath.Recently I've checked the SSE optimized utMath [utMath_rc3] for problems and comparing the returned results from original utMath with utMath_rc3.But sometimes [not too much] utMath_rc3 returns -0 instead of 0.This happend a few times on Matrix4f class : Inverted() .

I've tested the code with MinGW/GCC 3.4.5 compiler and there isn't any -0 , only MSVC [2005] returns -0 !

Do you have any idea about why MSVC compiled code generates -0 ?

[I'm using winxp sp2 + PentiumIII 750MHz + 256MB RAM SD]

-0 is the same as 0, it is just an artefact of the binary representation of numbers. Some standard library implementations print -0 as 0, and some don't.

_________________
Tristam MacDonald - [swiftcoding]

I fear that this will be problematic in future and generate runtime errors because they are float types

Why would it cause any problems? They are exactly the same number, just with a slightly different representation in bits. For a float you have some number of bits containing the value, and an additional bit for the sign. Flipping the sign bit negates the number, so flipping the sign bit on 0 gives you -0.

You can check for yourself that the sign on zero doesn't matter for any basic operations:

n + 0.0 = n and n - 0.0 = n
n * 0.0 = 0.0 and n * (-0.0) = -0.0
n / 0.0 = INF and n/(-0.0) = INF
0.0 == -0.0 => True

Remember, -0 does not exist - it is merely an artefact of the binary representation of floating point numbers, and affects nothing except the print function. If you look at the IEEE spec for floating point, you will also see that there can be multiple representations for INF and NAN.

_________________
Tristam MacDonald - [swiftcoding]

From Wikipedia:

Thank you very much dear marciano and swiftcoder

I am more concerned about matrix multiplication and floats

If i may be so bold as to recommend you read Essential Mathematics for Games (2nd edition) first chapter deals with numerical representations (i think this chapter is available for free, but i am not certain). It tackles this topic and others that you may find interesting.

Thanks a lot dear DDd